Panasonic
HC-X1600
Mid-tier 4K60p camcorder with 1/2.5-inch MOS sensor, 24x 25–600mm zoom, 3G-SDI, face-detection AF, and USB-PD power.
$1,699
Launch priceReleased Mar 2021
Panasonic
Lumix S5 II
Phase-detect L-mount hybrid with 6K open gate and strong video tools.
$1,999
Launch priceReleased Jan 2023
Lumix S5 II is 1.8 years newer.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Cameraegg earns from qualifying purchases. Cameraegg may also earn commission from B&H links, at no extra cost to you.
Wins
HC-X1600
Wins
Lumix S5 II
6 categories tied
Which would you choose?
TL;DR — Key differences
- BLumix S5 II has higher AF points / zones (779 vs 225)
- BLumix S5 II has higher RAW buffer depth (200 frames vs 60 frames)
- BLumix S5 II has higher Resolution (24.2 MP vs 8.29 MP)
- BLumix S5 II has higher ISO max (native) (51,200 vs 25,600)
- BLumix S5 II has higher Burst (electronic) (30 fps vs 15 fps)
Key specs at a glance
Size and weight, to scale
📸 Snap this size diff to shareHC-X1600
134 × 91 × 72 mm
580 g (1.28 lb / 20.46 oz)
Credit card
85.6 × 54 mm
for scale
Lumix S5 II
134 × 102 × 90 mm
740 g (1.63 lb / 26.10 oz)
HC-X1600 is 11mm shorter and 18mm thinner than Lumix S5 II.
HC-X1600 is 160 g lighter than Lumix S5 II.
Depth (front-to-back): 72mm HC-X1600 · 90mm Lumix S5 II
Back view, to scale
Width × Height — same proportions as the front of the body.
HC-X1600
134 × 91 mm
Credit card
85.6 × 54 mm
Lumix S5 II
134 × 102 mm
Top view, to scale
Width × Depth (front-to-back) — see which body is chunkier on the table.
HC-X1600
134 × 72 mm
Credit card
85.6 × 54 mm
Lumix S5 II
134 × 90 mm
Sensor size, to scale
HC-X1600
17.3 × 13 mm · Micro Four Thirds
225 mm² area
Lumix S5 II
35.6 × 23.8 mm · Full Frame
847 mm² area
3.8× larger sensor area = shallower depth of field and better low-light performance.
Use-case scoring
Which one for what?
Algorithmic scores from verified specs · 10 = best in class
Why pick one over the other
Reasons to choose
HC-X1600
Dimensions (W×H×D mm)
Adds 134, 91, 72
AA filter
Only HC-X1600 supports it
Subject recognition
Adds Bird, Vehicle
Pre-Capture / Pre-Release
Only HC-X1600 supports it
Battery life (CIPA)
640 shots vs 370 shots — higher is better
Codecs
Adds ProRes
Weight
580 g vs 740 g — lower is better
IBIS effectiveness
6 stops vs 5 stops — higher is better
Reasons to choose
Lumix S5 II
AF low-light limit
-6 EV vs -4 EV — lower is better
Dimensions (W×H×D mm)
Adds 134.3, 102.3, 90.1
AF points / zones
779 vs 225 — higher is better
RAW buffer depth
200 frames vs 60 frames — higher is better
Subject recognition
Adds Face, Eye, Car…
Resolution
24.2 MP vs 8.29 MP — higher is better
ISO max (native)
51,200 vs 25,600 — higher is better
Burst (electronic)
30 fps vs 15 fps — higher is better
Both cameras share
- ✓ISO min (native) — Both 100
- ✓Eye AF — Both support eye af
- ✓Animal / bird AF — Both support animal / bird af
- ✓4K max frame rate — Both 60 fps
- ✓Max video bit rate — Both 200 Mbps
- ✓Internal RAW video — Both support internal raw video
Pros & cons at a glance
Editorially curated highlights and trade-offs.
HC-X1600
Pros
- ✓4K 60p internal recording
- ✓24x f/1.8–4.0 optical zoom
- ✓3G-SDI + full HDMI output
- ✓Face Detection AF/AE
- ✓USB-PD + dual SD slots
Cons
- –1/2.5-inch sensor
- –No XLR without handle unit
- –Smaller sensor than HC-X2
- –Superseded by HC-X2100 in lineup
Lumix S5 II
Pros
- ✓Phase-detect AF finally
- ✓6K open gate
- ✓IBIS
- ✓Great value
Cons
- –24MP resolution
- –L-mount size
- –AF still behind Canon/Sony
Decided which one is right for you?
Compare live prices for the HC-X1600 and Lumix S5 II at major authorized retailers.
Panasonic HC-X1600
Panasonic Lumix S5 II
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Cameraegg earns from qualifying purchases. Cameraegg may also earn commission from B&H links, at no extra cost to you.
Full specifications
✓ = category winner
Frequently asked
Quick answers generated from verified specs.
Which is better for portraits, HC-X1600 or Lumix S5 II?
Lumix S5 II scores 8.5/10 versus 4.0/10 for HC-X1600 — 24.2MP — solid resolution.
What's the resolution difference between the HC-X1600 and Lumix S5 II?
HC-X1600 is 8.29 MP and Lumix S5 II is 24.2 MP, so the Lumix S5 II captures more detail for cropping and large prints.
Do the HC-X1600 and Lumix S5 II have in-body image stabilization?
HC-X1600 has 6-stop in-body image stabilization, while Lumix S5 II has 5-stop in-body image stabilization.
Which shoots faster bursts — the HC-X1600 or the Lumix S5 II?
HC-X1600 reaches 15 fps electronic. Lumix S5 II reaches 30 fps electronic.
What's the weight difference between the HC-X1600 and Lumix S5 II?
HC-X1600 weighs 580 g and Lumix S5 II weighs 740 g, so the HC-X1600 is 160 g lighter.
Do the HC-X1600 and Lumix S5 II record 4K video?
HC-X1600: 4K up to 60p. Lumix S5 II: 6K Open Gate (max), 4K up to 60p.
Are the HC-X1600 and Lumix S5 II weather sealed?
HC-X1600: Yes. Lumix S5 II: Yes.
Which has better battery life?
Rated battery life is 640 shots (CIPA) for the HC-X1600 and 370 shots for the Lumix S5 II, giving the HC-X1600 the edge.
How much does each cost?
HC-X1600 launched at $1,699 and Lumix S5 II at $1,999. The HC-X1600 is $300 less.
Can't decide between two? Compare a third camera.
Add any camera to get a three-way HC-X1600 vs Lumix S5 II vs X comparison.
Specs sourced from manufacturer data. Use-case scores algorithmically derived. Last reviewed June 2026.
Product images courtesy of Panasonic press materials.